Ender 5 S1 vs Bambu P1P: A Comparison of 3D Printers

Introduction

Choosing the right 3D printer can be a daunting task, especially with so many options available on the market. The Ender 5 S1 vs Bambu P1P are both popular choices, each with its own unique strengths and capabilities. By providing you with a comprehensive analysis of these printers, we aim to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

Throughout this article, we will examine various aspects of these two printers, including their technical specifications, printing capabilities, user-friendliness, and overall value for money. We will also highlight any notable differences between the two models, allowing you to identify which printer is better suited to your individual requirements.

Ender 5 S1 vs Bambu P1P: Key Features and Specifications

Parameter	Ender-5 S1	Bambu P1P
Molding Technology	FDM	FDM
Build Volume	220 x 220 x 280mm	256 x 256 x 256 mm³
Product Dimensions	425 x 460 x 570mm	386 x 389 x 458 mm³
Package Dimensions	528 x 474 x 340mm	Package size: 485 x 480 x 528 mm³
Net Weight	12.1kg	Net weight: 9.65 kg
Gross Weight	14.7kg	Gross weight: 14.3 kg
Extruder Type	“Sprite” dual-gear direct drive extruder	direct drive
Extruder Material	All metal	All metal
Leveling Mode	CR Touch auto-leveling	auto-leveling
Nozzle Type	Brass nozzle x1	Stainless Steel
Filament Diameter	1.75mm	1.75mm
Nozzle Temperature	≤300°C	Max Hot End Temperature: 300 ℃
Heatbed Temperature	≤110°C	Max Build Plate Temperature: 100℃
Build Surface	PC spring steel sheet	Compatibility with multiple build plate surfaces
Power Loss Recovery	Yes	yes
Filament Runout Sensor	Yes	yes
Rated Voltage	100-120V~, 200-240V~, 50/60Hz	100-240 VAC, 50/60 Hz
Rated Power	350W	1000W@220V, 350W@110V
Supported Filaments	PLA, PETG, ABS, TPU, PC, ASA, HIPS	Ideal: PLA, PETG, TPU, PVA, PET
Slicing Software	Creality Slicer, Creality Print, Cura, Repetier-Host, Simplify3D	Bambulab studio
Chamber Monitoring Camera	No	Low Rate Camera 1280 x 720 / 0.5fps
Timelapse Supported	No	Supported
Max Speed of Tool Head	250mm/s	500 mm/s

When comparing the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P, it is important to consider their key features and specifications. Both printers offer unique qualities that cater to different needs and preferences.

Build Volume and Printing Area

The Ender 5 S1 boasts a generous printing area of 220 x 220 x 250mm, allowing users to create medium-sized prints with ease. On the other hand, the Bambu P1P offers a larger printing area of 256 x 256 x 256mm, providing more space for larger and more complex models. This difference in build volume can be a deciding factor for those who require a larger printing area.

Printing Speed and Precision

In terms of printing speed, both printers offer similar performance. The Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P can operate at speeds of up to 300mm/s to 400mm/s, ensuring efficient and timely printing. However, it is worth noting that the Bambu P1P has a maximum printing speed of 500 mm/s, which may be advantageous for users who prioritize speed.

When it comes to precision, both printers deliver accurate and high-quality prints. The Bambu P1P, being a CoreXY printer, offers a more stable and precise printing experience compared to the Ender 5 S1’s Cartesian kinematics. This can result in better parts that fit together seamlessly, making the Bambu P1P a favorable choice for those who require precise and intricate prints.

User Interface and Software

The user interface and software of a 3D printer play a crucial role in its overall usability. The Ender 5 S1 features a user-friendly interface with a touchscreen display, allowing for easy navigation and control. On the other hand, the Bambu P1P has a simple LCD screen and a rotary knob, which may require multiple clicks to access certain functions.

In terms of software, both printers offer their own remote control apps that enable users to operate the printers efficiently. However, the Bambu P1P’s app is known for its simplicity and contains only the necessary functions required to control the printer. This streamlined approach can be appealing to users who prefer a straightforward and hassle-free experience.

Price and Value

When it comes to price, both the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P are priced similarly, making them competitive options in the market. However, it is important to consider the overall value that each printer offers. The Bambu P1P comes with additional features such as a camera and an auxiliary fan, but it requires separate purchases for a box enclosure and air venting treatment to achieve its best performance. On the other hand, the Ender 5 S1 offers a fully enclosed design and does not require additional purchases for optimal performance.

In conclusion, the key features and specifications of the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P provide users with different options to suit their specific needs. The Ender 5 S1 offers a reliable printing experience with its fully enclosed design and user-friendly interface. On the other hand, the Bambu P1P provides a larger printing area and a more precise printing experience, making it a suitable choice for those who prioritize size and accuracy. Ultimately, the decision between the two printers depends on individual preferences and requirements.

Print Quality and Performance

When it comes to comparing the print quality and performance of the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P, both 3D printers offer exceptional results. Each machine has its own unique features and capabilities that contribute to the overall print quality.

The Ender 5 S1, with its cartesian kinematics, provides reliable and accurate prints. With proper tuning and calibration, users can achieve high-quality prints that meet their expectations. The printer’s sturdy frame and stable construction contribute to its ability to produce precise and detailed models. Whether you’re printing functional parts or artistic designs, the Ender 5 S1 delivers consistent and impressive results.

On the other hand, the Bambu P1P takes print quality and performance to the next level with its CoreXY design. This design allows for faster print speeds and smoother movement of the print head. The P1P’s CoreXY kinematics, combined with its powerful extruder and advanced motion control system, result in exceptional print quality. Users can expect sharp details, clean lines, and accurate dimensions in their prints. Additionally, the P1P’s larger printing area provides more flexibility in terms of the size of models that can be produced.

Both printers offer excellent print quality, but the Bambu P1P has an edge in terms of speed. With a maximum printing speed of 500mm/s, the P1P can complete prints in a fraction of the time compared to the Ender 5 S1. This can be particularly advantageous for users who require fast turnaround times or need to produce multiple prints in a short period.

It’s important to note that print quality and performance can also be influenced by factors such as filament type, print settings, and proper calibration. Users should take the time to fine-tune their printers and experiment with different settings to achieve the best results.

Ease of Use and Setup

The Ender 5 S1 comes partially assembled, which means you will need to spend some time putting it together before you can start printing. While this may be a drawback for those who are new to 3D printing or prefer a more plug-and-play experience, it can also be a benefit for those who enjoy the process of building their own printer and want more control over its setup.

On the other hand, the Bambu P1P comes fully assembled, so you can start printing right out of the box. This can be a huge advantage for beginners or those who prefer a hassle-free setup. The P1P also comes with an automatic leveling feature, which makes the bed leveling process much easier and more convenient.

Both printers offer intuitive interfaces that allow you to navigate through the settings and control the printer with ease. The Ender 5 S1 features a touch screen display, which provides a user-friendly and interactive experience. The Bambu P1P, on the other hand, has a small touch screen that may require multiple clicks to access certain functions, but it still provides a straightforward and efficient way to control the printer.

In terms of software, both printers support popular slicing software such as Bambu Studio, PrusaSlicer, Simplify3D, and Cura. These software options offer a range of features and customization options to optimize your prints. However, it’s worth noting that the Ender 5 S1’s software may have more advertisements, while the P1P’s software focuses on providing only the necessary functions for printer control.

Upgradability and Customization

The Ender 5 S1, being part of the Creality Ender series, benefits from a wide range of upgrade options available in the market. Creality has built a strong community of users who actively share tips, tricks, and modifications to improve the performance and capabilities of their Ender printers. From upgraded hotends and extruders to improved cooling systems and bed leveling mechanisms, there is no shortage of options to take your Ender 5 S1 to the next level.

On the other hand, the Bambu P1P offers a unique approach to customization. With its modular design and PlateMod system, users have the freedom to create and attach their own 3D printed sides to the printer. This not only allows for aesthetic customization but also opens up possibilities for functional upgrades. Bambu Lab provides a library of PlateMod designs that users can download and print, or they can create their own designs to suit their specific needs. Additionally, the P1P supports the Automatic Material System (AMS), which enables users to add multiple filament reels for multi-color printing.

Both printers offer users the ability to upgrade and customize their machines, but the approaches are different. The Ender 5 S1 benefits from a well-established ecosystem of upgrades, while the Bambu P1P offers a more hands-on and creative approach to customization.

In terms of ease of installation and compatibility, the Ender 5 S1 has the advantage of being part of the Creality family. This means that upgrades and modifications designed for other Creality printers, such as the Ender 5 Pro or the CR-10, are often compatible with the Ender 5 S1 as well. This makes it easier for users to find and install upgrades without having to worry about compatibility issues.

On the other hand, the Bambu P1P’s PlateMod system allows for easy installation and customization. Users can simply download the PlateMod design they want, print it, and attach it to the printer. This gives users the freedom to experiment and create their own unique look and functionality for their P1P.

Software and Interface

The Ender 5 S1 comes with Creality Slicer, a customized version of Cura, which provides a familiar and reliable slicing software for users. With built-in print profiles specifically designed for the Ender 5 S1, users can easily set up their prints and adjust settings according to their preferences. The software also allows for seamless integration with PrusaSlicer, giving users the flexibility to slice their models using different software options. Additionally, the Ender 5 S1 is compatible with various operating systems, including Windows, macOS, and Linux, ensuring accessibility for a wide range of users.

On the other hand, the Bambu P1P offers its own slicing software called Bambu Studio. This software is known for its refined and precise interface, which has been optimized to provide a seamless user experience. Bambu Studio eliminates unnecessary elements and focuses on the essential functions required to control the printer. Whether you are a beginner or an experienced user, Bambu Studio offers a user-friendly interface that caters to your needs.

Both printers also have their own remote control apps, allowing users to operate them easily and efficiently over a local network or through 5G technology. While the Creality K1 app may have more advertisements, including files from the Creality Cloud, the Bambu P1P’s app focuses solely on the necessary functions required to control the printer.

In terms of DIY customization, both printers offer opportunities for users to modify and upgrade their machines. The open-source nature of the Ender 5 S1 allows users to explore various modifications and enhancements, such as adding auto bed leveling or upgrading the extruder. Similarly, the Bambu P1P provides a platform for users to customize their printer according to their specific needs and preferences.

Price and Value

In terms of price, the Ender 5 S1 is priced at $559, while the P1P is also sold at $599. However, it’s important to note that the P1P comes with additional accessories such as a camera and an auxiliary fan, while the Ender 5 S1 does not. To achieve the ultimate performance with the P1P, you may need to purchase a separate box enclosure and carry out some air venting treatment, which can add to the overall cost.

Considering the value, both printers offer similar printing quality and performance. The P1P has a larger printing area of 256*256*256 compared to the Ender 5 S1’s 220*220*250. However, in terms of printing speed, both machines operate at a similar range of approximately 300mm/s to 400mm/s.

It’s worth noting that the Ender 5 S1 comes with the Creality Sonic Pad, which allows for the installation of Klipper firmware. This firmware brings advanced features such as improved print speeds and network connectivity. This added value can enhance the overall printing experience and make the Ender 5 S1 a more versatile option.

When considering the price and value, it ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize a larger printing area and additional accessories, the P1P may be the better choice for you. However, if you value the flexibility and advanced features offered by the Sonic Pad and Klipper firmware, the Ender 5 S1 could provide a higher value proposition.

Conclusion

In the end, the choice between the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P boils down to your individual needs, preferences, and budget. Both printers offer impressive features and capabilities, ensuring a satisfying 3D printing experience. Whether you prioritize reliability, accuracy, speed, print size, or overall print quality, both the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P have the capabilities to meet your requirements.

Consider your needs, weigh the pros and cons, and choose the printer that aligns best with your 3D printing journey. Whichever path you choose, rest assured that both the Ender 5 S1 and the Bambu P1P will guide you towards creating amazing prints and unleashing your creativity.